Transporting an Open Container Archives

F-2016-696

Post author:Staff
Post published:September 21, 2017
Post category:F

In OCCA case No. F-2016-696, Mesfun appealed his conviction for driving under the influence of alcohol, transporting an open container of liquor, driving without a license, and driving left of center. In a published decision, the court decided to modify the sentence on one count and affirmed the rest of the judgment. One justice dissented. Mesfun was found guilty of multiple offenses in Tulsa County District Court. The charges included driving drunk, having an open container of alcohol while driving, not having a driver's license, and driving in the wrong lane. He received a long sentence, including years in prison and fines, to be served one after the other. Mesfun's appeal included three main points. First, he argued that the jury was wrongly told how much punishment they could give him for transporting an open container of liquor. The court agreed with him on this point and changed that sentence to a shorter jail time and fine. Second, Mesfun claimed that the prosecutor acted unfairly during the trial, which hurt his chances of a fair trial. However, the court found that the prosecutor's comments were allowed and did not harm Mesfun's case. Third, he said that his lawyer did not do a good job to help him. The court looked at this claim and said that his lawyer's actions did not affect the trial's outcome, so this point was also denied. Overall, the court modified one part of his sentence but upheld the rest of the decision from the trial court.

M-2002-1195

Post author:Staff
Post published:August 10, 2004
Post category:M

In OCCA case No. M-2002-1195, Anita Shank appealed her conviction for Driving Under the Influence, Transporting an Open Container of Beer, and Obstructing an Officer. In a published decision, the court decided to affirm her convictions for Transporting an Open Container and Obstructing an Officer, but modified her Driving Under the Influence conviction to Driving While Impaired and remanded the case for sentence modification. One judge dissented. Anita Shank was found guilty of driving under the influence of alcohol, transporting open containers of beer, and obstructing an officer during her trial. She received a 90-day sentence for driving under the influence and fines for the other two charges. Shank contested her convictions on several grounds, claiming the evidence was insufficient and arguing errors regarding jury instructions and sentencing. During the trial, it was noted that Shank was stopped by a sheriff's deputy while she was driving and had an open container of beer in her car. The deputy observed signs of intoxication, like bloodshot eyes. Shank admitted to drinking two beers but refused to take a breathalyzer test. When questioned about the whereabouts of her child, she lied and was uncooperative. The court found that there was enough evidence to support her conviction for driving under the influence but acknowledged that the jury should have been instructed on the possibility of a lesser offense—Driving While Impaired. The state agreed that not instructing on this was an error, although they deemed it harmless. Additionally, Shank argued the trial court should have considered a suspended sentence for her. The record did not show that the court completely ignored this request, but the judge did express a need for proof of her willingness to enter treatment for alcohol issues. After the appeal, it was revealed that Shank completed the treatment program, prompting the court to order the lower court to consider this when evaluating her suspended sentence request. The court upheld the obstruction conviction, stating that her deliberate lies and refusal to cooperate with the deputy interfered with the execution of his duties, which constitutes sufficient grounds for the charge. In conclusion, while Shank's obstruction of an officer and open container convictions were affirmed, her DUI was modified to a lesser charge of DWI, and the court directed the district court to revisit her request for a suspended sentence.