F-2017-1279
In OCCA case No. F-2017-1279, Dakota James Alleyn Shriver appealed his conviction for Second Degree Murder, Accessory After the Fact, and misdemeanor Obstructing an Officer. In an unpublished decision, the court decided that the State of Oklahoma did not have jurisdiction to prosecute him. One judge dissented. Dakota Shriver was found guilty by a jury and sentenced to serve time for various charges. Shriver argued that he should not have been tried in state court because he is a citizen of the Cherokee Nation and the crime happened on land that is considered Indian Country. This argument was based on a previous case, McGirt v. Oklahoma, which changed how some crimes are viewed depending on whether they happen on Native American land. The court decided to look into these claims further and sent the case back to the lower court to gather more information. The lower court held a hearing to determine if Shriver was indeed an Indian and if the crime occurred on a reservation. After the hearing, the lower court found Shriver was a member of the Cherokee Nation and that the crime did happen within the boundaries set for the reservation. The evidence showed that Shriver had a certain amount of Cherokee blood and was a recognized member of the Cherokee Nation at the time of the crime. The court found that the United States Congress had established a reservation for the Cherokee Nation, and no evidence existed to prove that Congress had removed those boundaries. Both parties were allowed to respond to the findings from the lower court. Shriver's team argued that the court should agree with the lower court's findings because they were backed by the evidence presented. The state agreed with these findings but asked for time to look at the case again in terms of whether they could charge Shriver under different laws. After considering everything, the court agreed with the findings of the lower court and decided that the state did not have the right to prosecute Shriver. Therefore, they overturned the convictions and told the lower court to dismiss the case.