F-2019-496
In OCCA case No. F-2019-496, Patrick Wayne Olive appealed his conviction for Trafficking in Illegal Drugs, Speeding in a Posted Zone, and Possession of Contraband in a Penal Institution. In a published decision, the court decided to vacate Olive's convictions and remand the case with instructions to dismiss. One judge dissented. Olive was convicted in the District Court of Muskogee County on three charges and sentenced to thirty-two years for drug trafficking, along with fines and jail time for the other charges. Olive argued that the court did not have the right to prosecute him because he is an enrolled member of the Cherokee Nation and the crimes took place within the boundaries of the Muscogee (Creek) Reservation. The OCCA reviewed Olive's claims and found that he indeed had Indian heritage and was a registered member of the Cherokee Nation at the time of the offenses. They confirmed that the crimes occurred within the Creek Reservation. The court's decision relied heavily on a previous Supreme Court case called McGirt v. Oklahoma, which determined that Oklahoma lacks jurisdiction over crimes committed by Native Americans in certain areas recognized as reservations. Because of this ruling, the OCCA concluded that the Muskogee County District Court did not have the authority to prosecute Olive. After considering all the evidence and arguments, the court vacated Olive's judgment and sentence and directed the lower court to dismiss the charges against him. This meant that Olive's criminal convictions were erased, and he would not serve the sentences that had been handed down.